Although I did eventually manage to track down some paper goods and I got the last of the foam craft kits at Michaels, I couldn't find a party game I liked for my 4 year old twins' class. So, I decided to just make my own. It's played like "Pin the Tail on the Donkey" but with a Thanksgiving twist. My kids loved playing "Put the Hat on the Turkey!"
You find this printable here. This Thanksgiving game is perfect for a party! The poster is formatted to be as large as 24" x 36' so you can print it at this size or scale it down. It can be printed at your local shop or you can order online at uprinting.com. Just a note- the actual poster does not have a hat on the turkey. It's featured this way to show you the completed look. The Pilgrim hats are in PDF format and there are two to a page. Just print as many copies as you need.
Your party is sure to be a blast with this cute game!